dragonimp: (One of those days)
dragonimp ([personal profile] dragonimp) wrote2009-04-05 12:27 pm
Entry tags:

FMA: Brotherhood

Just finished watching the premiere episode of the new FMA. My reaction was a resounding:

Meh.

It's probably just this episode. It felt too cramped. They were trying to introduce too many characters and too many concepts at once. One of the great things about FMA - both the manga and the original anime - was the gradual way the story played out. This felt rushed. Once the story proper gets going it'll probably be fine, but I really wasn't impressed by the pacing or the storytelling here.

Also, based on the teasers, I was expecting a lot more from the animation. It had its moments, but it also felt awkward.

It's going to take me a while to get used to Roy's new voice, too. It just doesn't have the depth and resonance I'm used to.

Riza wins for one-liners, though: "Please only be useless on rainy days, sir."

[identity profile] dragonimp.livejournal.com 2009-04-05 08:58 pm (UTC)(link)
Roy sounded... I think it hit me as "young" so much as ... thin. Washed-out. It's like there was nothing behind it. Which is unfortunate, because manga!Roy is so much more centered and grounded than first-anime!Roy, he should sound more authoritative, not less.

Yeah, that quiche was out of nowhere. I mean, I sure she made a lot of things, but frugal country living = quiche??

(And Armstrong showing up with roses and then doing that "go ahead, touch me!!" line? I was like "OMG pedophile alchemist!!" Armstrong is a sap and a fop, but he's not supposed to be a pervert!)